Was rockefeller a robber baron or a captain of industry which accurately describes morgan, carnegie, and rockefeller, industrial statesmen or robber barons considering the fact that we put men like carnegie, rockefeller, and mellon on a pedestal, why were they called robber -barons. Best answer: they were both - robber barons was another name for the guilded age captains of industry they weren't interested in anything but making as much money as possible they weren't interested in anything but making as much money as possible. The giants of us industry took place during the early late 19th and early 20th centuries - captains of industry essay introduction the four giants of industrialization were vanderbilt, carnegie, morgan and rockefeller. Aim: were carnegie, morgan, rockefeller, and vanderbilt robber barons or captains of industry claim: carnegie, morgan, rockefeller, and vanderbilt were captains of industry. He is a captain of the industry because he was an innovator, he gave back a lot by making carnegie hall and making many colleges in 1902 carnegie founded the carnegie institution to fund scientific reasearch, he also established a pension fund for teachers with a $10 million dollar donation.
Were the captains of industry good for the country on saturday we were introduced to two historians from the university of maryland, jon franklin (pro) and david sicilia (con) after hearing both sides of what the captains carnegie, rockefeller and jp morgan of industry did for our society, i have concluded that the robber barons. Andrew carnegie's essay, gospel of wealth (1889) struck a chord in john d rockefeller and strengthened his resolve to support worthy causes several major philanthropic institutions resulted in 1913, the last, the rockefeller foundation, which has given away over $2 billion in grants, was chartered. Best answer: were carnegie, rockefeller, pullman, and ford robber barons or captains of industry probably the best answer to that question is an emphatic yes probably the best answer to that question is an emphatic yes. Captains of industry, however, were often philanthropists they made their wealth in a way that would benefit society, such as providing more jobs or increasing productivity john d rockefeller.
In my opinion rockefeller and carnegie were captains of industry john d rockefeller formed the standard oil company in 1870 one of the first things that he had to deal with was the high cost of transporting the barrels of oil to his refineries in cleveland, ohio. John davison rockefeller, is known for being one of the richest men on the planet his fortune was worth over $300,000,000,000 when he died in 1937 most people who were close to having a 10th of his money were mostly robber barons rockefeller was considered a captain of industry because he. Goal/aim/purpose: to determine whether rockefeller and carnegie were robber barons or captains of industry and to speculate on which ceos or leaders of industry today fit this model.
American industrialists such as rockefeller, carnegie, hill, and vanderbilt , as a majority, were captains of industry rather than robber barons, in my opinion these men were not spoon fed the success they needed to own giant corporations, but worked hard and learned the ticks of the trade. One of the captains of industry of 19th century america, andrew carnegie helped build the formidable american steel industry, a process that turned a poor young man into the richest man in the. Andrew carnegie, john davison rockefeller, and john pierpont morgan: captains of industry - in the years following the civil war, the american economy was suffering from extreme disorder.
Often these men were called the captains or masters of industry you may have heard of names like john d rockefeller, andrew carnegie, and jp morgan we'll take a look at the lives of these men, as well as a few others, and examine how their development of major industries and business practices affected america's economy. In research paper help the late captains of industry andrew carnegie and john d rockefeller 19th century a captain of industry was a business leader whose means of amassing a personal fortune contributed positively to the country in some way john d free shipping on qualifying offers. Andrew carnegie and john d rockefeller captains of industry, or robber barons true, andrew carnegie and john d rockefeller may have been the most influential businessmen of the 19th century, but was the way they conducted business proper.
Industries that were built by men such as cornelius vanderbilt, andrew carnegie, jp morgan, and john d rockefeller led to the eventual greater good for all and opened doors for advancements in. They were praised for their skills as well as for their philanthropy (charity) in reality the debate over robber barons and captains of industry mirrors views of industrialism itself just as their were both positives and negatives to industrialism there were positives and negatives to the leaders of industrialism. Captains of industry or robber barons overview: the thirty years plus, following the end of the civil war, is often referred to as the gilded age this was a term coined by mark twain, the most renowned american writer of the period. John d rockefeller was called a robber baron because many people believed he used unethical business practices to amass his extraordinary wealth the term robber baron was coined in the 19th century to describe a group of industrialists who were creating enormous personal fortunes.
Rockefeller and carnegie were captains of industry john d rockefeller formed the standard oil company in 1870 one of the first things that he had to deal with was the high cost of transporting the barrels of. John d rockefeller andrew carnegie cornelius vanderbilt j p morgan overview: the thirty years plus, following the end of the civil war, is often referred to as the gilded age.
Despite rockefeller still being worth three times more than carnegie, the scotsman donates ever increasing amounts of his fortune homestead carnegie invests millions to turn around the homestead steel works, a struggling steel mill outside pittsburgh, to increase the production of structural steel. Carnegie, rockefeller, and vanderbilt should be considered as captains of industry and not robber barons they are industrial tycoons and should be considered as captains of industry because they used their business skills to strengthen the economy. Andrew carnegie, jp morgan, john d rockefeller robber barons or captains of industry were these men captains of industry, whom this country needed to take its place as a great industrial power, or were they robber barons, limiting healthy competition and robbing from the poor to benefit the rich.