Haig did not win the war, and it is not true that attrition was the only way to win it if haig had shown more flexibility and imagination, consulted more, or tried experiment, innovation or enterprise, the war could have been won sooner, with fewer losses. ' depending on which one you believe answers the question, one tells that haig was a war winner, and one tells the opposite, he was a butcher although this extract may also be biased but in the other way, because the man who wrote it was bound to feel hatred towards the commanding offices for the war and battle its self. I think, unless it won us the war, (which it clearly didn't) that many deaths cannot be in any way good ~0~ to conclude, i'm sure that you can guess my verdict i believe that haig was a butcher.
Get this from a library general haig : butcher or war winner [josh brooman. Does haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme feild marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career haig decided to attack the germans at the river somme in 1916 to attract german. Strategically, haig got it right for britain and france the western front was where the war would have to be won any diversion from it was a distraction he must be held accountable for the battles of the somme and passchendaele, but he must by the same token be given credit for the final victory.
Field marshal haig: the butcher of the somme field marshal haig: the butcher of the somme field marshal haig was a successful army official who won the boer war back in south africa fifteen years before the war - field marshal haig: the butcher of the somme introduction. If haig deserves credit for winning the war as con claims, despite the contributions of his other officers, then surely he also deserves credit for the butchery of the somme despite the contributions of his other officers. Field marshall douglas haig is most associated with the battle of the somme in world war one douglas haig was britain's commander-in-chief during the somme battle and took much criticism for the sheer loss of life in this battle. Haig - has history been fair this was the starting point of the debate that brought to life the complexities of the great war the debate was chaired by bill brookman, the proposer was: dr neil faulkner (historian), the second proposer was dr ray sutton ma, phd (historian), the main opposer was dr matthew s. Haig who was seen as hero at the end of the war but was later labelled a 'butcher' by some historians his son george alexander eugene douglas haig, has spoken out to set the record straight.
After the battle of the somme, haig got the nickname butcher of the somme however after examining the battle in more detail, some people decided that he was a brilliant general who miscalculated, a hero of the war. Douglas haig: world war i's worst general sir douglas haig, chief of staff of the british expeditionary force (bef) was the architect of the greatest tragedyof the british national military history in world war i. To some, he will always be the man who won the war to others, he remains the butcher a century has passed since sir douglas haig was appointed commander-in-chief of the british. This earned haig a title the butcher of the somme this is because he didn't need to send the men into battle if he didn't understand the new ways of war plus that that many died, to gain almost nothing at all.
Field marshall douglas haig: butcher, bungler or hero the commander in chief when field-marshal earl haig died in 1928 it was estimated that at least one million people watched the funeral procession pass through the streets of london. Haig by contrast was of the opinion that the western front would be where the war would be fought and won. The battle of the somme was one of the costliest battles of world war i the original allied estimate of casualties on the somme, made at the chantilly conference on 15 november 1916, was 485,000 british and french casualties and 630,000 german. Was haig a butcher or war winner harvard case study solution and analysis of harvard business case studies solutions - assignment helpin most courses studied at harvard business schools, students are provided with a case study. Depending on which one you believe answers the question, one tells that haig was a war winner, and one tells the opposite, he was a butcher although this extract may also be biased but in the other way, because the man who wrote it was bound to feel hatred towards the commanding offices for the war and battle its self.
Haig was a hero because he had the strength of character to administer decisions that no ordinary man could ever make also, the british army won a series of victories unmatched in military history. World war 1 was trench warfare and in july 1916 field marshall douglas haig became the commander at the battle of the somme the battle of the somme was among the largest battles of the first world war and is one of the bloodiest military operations ever recorded. A century after the bloody battle of the somme of 1916 left at least 12 million british, french, and german soldiers killed, wounded, or captured, general douglas haig, commander of the british expeditionary force, remains one of the most controversial generals to emerge from world war i.
Hmm, could be some interesting replies to this one christine 'haig the butcher' is very much a 'take' on haig after his death in 1928 after the war he spent most of his time on the welfare of ex-servicemen (instigated the royal british legion, poppy appeal etc. General haig was a famous general who won the last war in the first world war, he should be remembered as a hero, but why do people reckon him to be the opposite, as a butcher as the ' butcher of the somme . The war changed peoples' thinking towards war from a great adventure, to a bloody event general douglas haig was one of the commanders from the british army in the battle of somme, the battle with one of the highest casualties in british military history. Haig who was seen as hero at the end of the war but was later labelled a 'butcher' by some his- torians his son george alexander eugene douglas haig, has spoken out to set the record straight.